“Zhanna, please don’t get upset right away, okay? My mom is coming over soon and she has a small favor to ask us.”
Zhanna stopped fastening her earring and looked at her husband through the hallway mirror.
“What do you mean, ‘don’t get upset’? I don’t even know what this is about yet.”
“That’s exactly why I’m telling you in advance. Just listen to her first.”
“Kirill, whenever you start with those words, it usually turns out someone already made a decision without me.”
“No one has decided anything.”
He said this a little too quickly, making Zhanna immediately suspicious. Their Saturday was supposed to be a relaxing breakfast, a trip for a new living room lamp, and finally sorting out the boxes on the top closet shelf. There were no family visits in their plans.
Ten minutes later, the doorbell rang.
Anna Sergeyevna entered confidently, as if she really had been expected. She took off her coat, sat on the bench, and placed a thick folder beside her. Zhanna noticed the folder right away but didn’t ask about it.
“Well, kids,” her mother-in-law began, “it’s a simple matter, and just temporary. There really isn’t much to discuss.”
“Then why did you come here?” Zhanna asked.
Kirill shot his wife an unhappy look.
“Zhanna, can’t you just talk normally?”
“I am talking normally, and I’m only asking a question.”
Anna Sergeyevna opened the folder.
“Sveta needs to get registered in the city. Both her and Artyom. For at least a year. Three would be even better, but we’ll see. You have a spacious apartment, great address, and there’s a good school nearby. It’s just very convenient for a child.”
It took Zhanna a moment to realize her mother-in-law was talking about their apartment. Or rather, her apartment.
“Wait. Registered where exactly?”
“Here, at your place.”
“At my place?”
“Well yes. Kirill said there wouldn’t be any problems.”
Zhanna slowly turned to her husband.
“What did you say?”
Kirill rubbed the back of his neck.
“I said we would discuss it.”
“No,” Anna Sergeyevna jumped in, “you said, ‘Mom, Zhanna will sign it, it’s not a big deal.’ I specifically checked, because Sveta needs to submit her paperwork soon.”
“Mom, why are you putting it that way?”
“How else should I say it? I’m just repeating what happened.”
Zhanna was silent for a few seconds. This apartment hadn’t come to her from her parents, or as an inheritance, or as a gift. She’d bought it at 31, before she even met Kirill, after years of tough saving. First there was a tiny one-bedroom on the outskirts, sold for a modest profit. Then three more years of saving, a loan for the rest, and almost two years without a proper vacation. By the time she and Kirill married, the loan was already paid off.
Kirill moved in with her. It never became an issue. Zhanna never threw around ‘my home’ in arguments, never reminded anyone who owned it, and never made her husband feel he should be grateful for having access to the bath or fridge. They just lived together.
But now it turned out that someone had interpreted this peacefulness a little too broadly.
“Why exactly am I supposed to register your daughter and her child at my apartment? Just because it’s convenient for you? No! And don’t tell me it’s ‘just a stamp’! If you want to help her, register her at your place, but stop trying to manage my home!”
Anna Sergeyevna was so surprised she even leaned back.
Now that’s how you start a conversation! I came over to talk to you face to face, like two adults.
«If you really wanted to handle things properly, you should’ve asked me first—not just shown up with completed forms after your son had already made promises on my behalf.»
«No one is taking your apartment away from you!»
«I never said you were.»
«Then what’s the problem?»
«The problem is that I don’t agree.»
«Is it because you just want to be difficult?»
«No, it’s because this is my apartment – and it’s my decision.»
That’s when Kirill finally stepped in:
«Zhanna, you’re turning this into a matter of principle on purpose. Sveta isn’t trying to take over your living space. She just needs to register so Artyom can get into a decent school and so she can sort out her own paperwork.»
«Then let her register at your mother’s place.»
«Why should I register your daughter and her child in my apartment? Just because it’s more convenient for you? No! And don’t try telling me that—»
Anna Sergeyevna instantly grimaced.
«My place is in a different neighborhood. And it’s tiny.»
«But there’s still space there for registration.»
«There is, but why should a child go to a school half the city away when there’s one just seven minutes from your place?»
«Because he’s your grandson, your daughter, and this should be your responsibility to help! How did I become the one expected to handle all this?»
«You’re Kirill’s wife. That makes you part of the family.»
«Being family doesn’t mean you get to distribute my property among relatives.»
«There you go again with ‘my property’!» Kirill snapped. «We’ve been living together for how many years now? Five. Does that make me a stranger here?»
«Are you trying to argue about your right to live here, or about registering your sister?»
«I just want you to stop acting like we’re asking you to hand over the apartment.»
«And I want you to stop promising my consent without talking to me first.»
That was the most unpleasant part of the whole conversation. It wasn’t even Anna Sergeyevna’s request. Truthfully, Svetlana was in a tough spot: recently divorced, staying temporarily at a friend’s place outside the city, hoping to find a job in town. Artyom was nine, and switching schools was proving difficult. Zhanna could have listened to her request—maybe she would’ve refused anyway, but at least the conversation would have been calm.
But now, nobody was calmly asking for anything. They just brought a ready-made solution, as if Zhanna’s signature was a mere formality.
Anna Sergeyevna spent another twenty minutes explaining that registration «doesn’t oblige you to anything,» that the child needed help, that Zhanna was being too suspicious, and that «normal people don’t get so obsessed with a few square meters.»
Zhanna’s replies got shorter and shorter.
«No.»
«But at least think about it.»
«No.»
«What did Sveta ever do to you?»
«Nothing. That’s why I’m not discussing her—I’m discussing your request.»
«This isn’t even a request anymore. It’s like some kind of test of your humanity!»
«Then I’ve failed that test. That’s it.»
When Anna Sergeyevna got up, her face was red with anger.
«You’re so greedy, Zhanna. And heartless. The apartment is huge, there’s just two of you living there, and you can’t even help your own family.»
«Artyom isn’t my family.»
«There! That one sentence says it all about you!»
«But he is to you—which is why, again, you should register them at your place.»
«I’ve said everything I need to Kirill. Let him sort this out with you.»
«Just make sure he remembers he’ll be sorting things out with me, not the apartment.»
After his mother left, Kirill stayed silent for a long time. Then he started tidying up the bench, picking up random little things, even though there was hardly anything there.
«Why did you treat her like that?»
Zhanna actually laughed.
«Are you serious right now?»
«You could have just refused her politely.»
«I did refuse politely during the first three minutes. After that, your mom spent another twenty-five trying to convince me my ‘no’ was wrong.»
«You kept bringing up the apartment.»
«Because we’re talking about an apartment.»
«But we’re husband and wife, after all.»
«And what exactly does that mean?»
«It shouldn’t be about ‘mine’ or ‘yours.’»
Zhanna looked at him closely.
«Great. Then tomorrow I’ll call your mom and say we’ve decided to sell her summer house. Svetlana needs the money more.»
«What does my mom’s summer house have to do with this?»
«And why did you immediately call it ‘your mom’s’?»
Kirill realized where she was going with this and turned away, annoyed.
«Don’t twist my words.»
«I’m not twisting anything. It’s easy to give away someone else’s property as long as it’s not yours, but mine.»
That evening, they barely spoke.
The next day, Kirill brought the topic up again at dinner.
«I talked to mom. She definitely went too far yesterday.»
«Alright.»
«But Svetlana is really struggling.»
Zhanna put her fork down.
«Kirill, the answer is no.»
«You didn’t even let me finish.»
«Because my answer won’t change.»
«Maybe even just for six months?»
«No.»
«Artyom has nothing to do with this.»
«I know.»
«So why should he have to suffer?»
«Why should his problem be solved through my apartment?»
«Because we can help!»
«You can. You have a salary, a car, free time, connections. Go ahead, help.»
Kirill took offense.
«So now we’re not a ‘we’ anymore?»
«Not when it comes to promises you made without me.»
From that evening on, the topic started coming up almost every day. Sometimes gently, sometimes with irritation.
Kirill kept coming up with new arguments.
The school is really good.
It’s a hassle for Svetlana to commute.
The boy needs a stable address.
His mom has trouble sleeping because of all this.
His sister felt hurt and now thinks that Zhanna hates her.
Every single time, Zhanna replied the same way:
«I do not give my consent.»
A week later, he tried a different approach.
«Do you realize that now Svetlana thinks I have no say in our family at all?»
«Are you more worried about what Svetlana thinks, or the fact that you really can’t make decisions about my apartment without me?»
«There you go again.»
«Yes. Again.»
«I’ve lived here for five years and invested in it.»
«Into utilities and groceries?»
«And not just that!»
«We built the bedroom closet together. You bought the TV. I’m not denying that. But that doesn’t make the apartment yours.»
«I’m not asking for a share!»
«Then why does it bother you so much that I decide who gets registered here?»
He didn’t answer.
Zhanna gradually realized that for Kirill, this wasn’t just about his sister. What really upset him was being turned down. As long as the apartment was just their shared home, everything was fine. But as soon as his family needed to use it, Kirill found Zhanna’s legal ownership suddenly uncomfortable and even insulting.
He started accusing her of ‘clinging to the apartment walls.’
«You’re supposed to hold on to family—not just the walls,» he said one evening.
— So, being a family—does that mean I have to agree with your mom all the time?
— Sometimes being a family means making compromises.
— Why do I have to be the one to compromise?
— Because it really doesn’t affect you in any big way.
— Then you compromise. Register your sister at your place.
— I don’t have an apartment.
— Exactly my point.
After that, Kirill went into the other room and barely said a word to her until late at night.
Anna Sergeevna wasn’t giving up either. She stopped calling Zhanna, but she called Kirill regularly. Sometimes he talked to her on the balcony, sometimes he didn’t bother, and Zhanna would catch snippets of their conversation.
— Mom, I’m talking to her.
— No, not yet.
— I told you, stop pressuring us.
— Well then, what do you expect me to do?
Almost every time after these calls, Kirill would be visibly irritated.
One day, Zhanna asked him:
— Is she still insisting you need to ‘put me in my place’?
Kirill shot her a sharp look.
— Are you eavesdropping?
— No. Your phone’s just loud.
— Mom’s just emotional right now.
— And you?
— What about me?
— Do you agree that I need to be put in my place?
— Don’t start.
— I’m not starting anything. I’m simply asking.
— No, I don’t agree.
But he didn’t sound particularly convincing when he said it.
On the ninth day, Svetlana herself finally called. Until then, she hadn’t contacted Zhanna at all, and Zhanna had even hoped that her sister-in-law might understand the awkwardness of the situation better than her mother or brother.
— Zhanna, hi. Is now a good time to talk?
— Yes, I can talk.
— I really don’t want to argue. I just want to understand why you’re so strongly against this.
Zhanna closed her work laptop and leaned back in her chair.
— Svetlana, it’s not about you. I’m against the fact that Kirill promised I’d agree before even discussing it with me, and then your mom came at me with her mind already made up.
— He told us you’d already discussed it.
— No. He told you that, but he never discussed anything with me.
There was silence on the other end of the line.
— I didn’t know.
— Well, now you do.
— But even aside from that… Would you still refuse?
— I wouldn’t agree.
— Why?
— Because I don’t want to register two more people at my apartment.
— But we’re not planning to actually live there.
— Maybe not today. But who knows what happens tomorrow? I just don’t want to get involved at all.
Svetlana took it personally:
— So you think I’m some kind of scammer?
— I never said that.
— But that’s what you mean.
— No, what I mean is, I don’t have to take on other people’s problems just because I happen to have a suitable address.
— Other people’s? I’m your husband’s sister.
— Yes, but that doesn’t make the apartment any less mine.
— Mom’s right. You really do cling to that apartment like it’s the most important thing in your life.
— That’s because I worked hard to buy it myself.
— So what, Kirill doesn’t count at all?
— Why does this always turn into that? Kirill is my husband, but he can’t be volunteering my consent to his relatives.
Svetlana let out an irritated sigh.
— Fine. I get it. It’s just a shame things turned out like this.
— I feel the same way. Especially since if you’d just asked me properly at the start, there wouldn’t have been any drama.
— But you still would have said ‘no,’ right?
— Yes.
After the conversation, Zhanna sat in the kitchen for another ten minutes, staring at the blank screen. She hated that, just like that, she became the person in the family who «didn’t help.» No one was talking about why Anna Sergeyevna didn’t want to register her daughter at her own place, why Svetlana wasn’t exploring other options, or why Kirill was offering someone else’s signature. The only thing being discussed: Zhanna had an apartment, and by family logic, that meant she was obliged to let others use it.
In the evening, Kirill came home already knowing about the conversation.
“Sveta cried after talking with you.”
“She didn’t cry when she was with me.”
“She cried afterwards.”
“And what am I supposed to do with that information?”
“Sometimes you could be a little softer.”
“Kirill, for a week now you’ve been trying to make me feel guilty because your sister didn’t get something that I never promised her.”
“She’s not a stranger.”
“And I’m not a free registration service.”
“You’re making everything about the formalities again.”
“No, you all did that. You picked my apartment as the most convenient solution, and now you’re telling me I have to share it.”
“I just want everyone to get along in the family.”
“Then start by not telling your relatives that I will definitely agree.”
He went to change clothes and came back half an hour later, a bit calmer.
“I really thought you wouldn’t mind.”
“Why?”
“Because you’ve always helped before.”
“Letting your mom borrow my car for a day and registering two people at my place—do you really see those as the same thing?”
“No.”
“Then why didn’t you ask me first?”
He shrugged.
“I don’t know. It just seemed like a minor thing.”
For the first time in days, Zhanna saw him actually pause and reflect—not just trying to convince her, but actually thinking about his own actions. But it didn’t last long.
Two days later, Anna Sergeyevna called him again in the evening. This time, Kirill accidentally put her on speaker when plugging in his phone to charge.
“Are you even talking to her?” Zhanna instantly recognized her mother-in-law’s voice. “Or did she say ‘no’ and you just gave up?”
Kirill quickly turned off the speakerphone, but it was too late.
“Mom, I’ll call you back.”
“No, you won’t call back, you’ll tell me now! Are you the man of the house or just a tenant?”
Kirill ended the call.
Zhanna stood by the table and watched him.
“So that’s why you keep talking about being ‘nobody’ in this house lately.”
“Don’t start.”
“Is she telling you that every single day?”
“She’s just worried about Sveta.”
“No. She’s telling you that if you can’t decide what happens with my apartment, then you’re not a real man.”
“Zhanna…”
“And then you bring that attitude home.”
“I’m not bringing anything.”
“Yesterday you asked why you never make decisions in our family. For five years before this, that question didn’t even bother you.”
Kirill sat down on the high stool by the kitchen.
“I don’t like that at any moment you can say, ‘It’s my apartment.’”
“I only say that when you try to decide who lives here or who is registered at my place.”
“Still.”
“Then it’s not a problem with the apartment. It’s about you hearing that from your mom and now trying to prove to her that you have authority here.”
He suddenly stood up.
“Don’t analyze me like that.”
«I’m not even trying to understand anymore. I’m just tired of someone else’s request turning into a test of your masculinity and my loyalty to the family.»
For the next two days, he really didn’t mention anything about the registration. Zhanna even thought that talking to his mother had ended up being harder on him than his wife’s refusal. But it turned out he was simply looking for another solution.
Almost three weeks passed. Outwardly, things at home became calmer. For a couple of days, Kirill didn’t bring up the idea of registration at all. Zhanna thought that topic had finally run its course.
On Saturday, they went grocery shopping. On the way back, Kirill got a message, read it, and quickly put his phone away.
«Sveta?» Zhanna asked.
«Yeah.»
«What does she want?»
«Nothing.»
«Then why do you look like that?»
«Like what?»
«Like someone who’s about to explain something unpleasant.»
«Zhanna, let’s talk at home.»
«No. Tell me now.»
He paused.
«I suggested an alternative to her.»
Zhanna could already tell nothing good was coming.
«What kind?»
«She could stay with us for a while. With Artyom.»
Zhanna turned her head.
«What?»
«Just temporarily. The room is empty anyway.»
In fact, there was a small second bedroom in the apartment that Zhanna used as an office and guest room. That’s what Kirill always referred to as the “spare room,” even though it had her desk, books, and a folding sofa.
«You suggested your sister move in with me?»
«With us.»
«Don’t start playing with words.»
«I thought that if you lived nearby, you’d see that Sveta doesn’t bother anyone. Then we could talk about the registration again, calmly this time.»
Zhanna stared at her husband for several seconds until he finally looked away.
«So you decided to settle them here first so I’d ‘get used to it,’ and then push for registration again?»
«I never said ‘push.’»
«What did you tell Sveta?»
«That I’d talk to you.»
«So you learned nothing from last time?»
«I didn’t promise her you’d agree.»
«But you still offered my home as a temporary place to stay.»
«There you go again—‘my home’!»
«Yes, Kirill. Mine. And that’s especially important right now.»
«You’re just being stubborn.»
«No. Let me make myself perfectly clear. If your sister and her child show up at this door with their things, you’ll be the first one out of the apartment. Not her. You. Because that would mean you’ve decided for the second time to force this on me.»
Kirill even smirked.
«You’d kick me out over my sister?»
«Over you.»
«Don’t make me laugh.»
«I’m not joking.»
He tried to argue for a few more minutes, but Zhanna didn’t raise her voice again.
«Call her now and tell her moving in isn’t an option.»
«I’ll handle it myself.»
«Fine. But if she shows up—you’ll be packing your things with her.»
That evening, Kirill really did call his sister. The conversation was unpleasant. Zhanna didn’t listen on purpose, but she could hear him say several times:
«No, Sveta, it’s not going to work.»
Then:
«Because it’s just not possible.»
And finally:
«If Mom wants, she can call me herself.»
Anna Sergeyevna called five minutes later.
This time Kirill went out onto the balcony and closed the door.
After the call, he came back looking grim.
«Well?» Zhanna asked.
«Nothing.»
«Did you put me in my place?»
«Very funny.»
«I’m not laughing.»
— Mom thinks you’re turning me against the family.
— And what do you think?
Kirill sat down across from her.
— I think that from the beginning, we could have helped and avoided all of this.
Zhanna nodded.
— So, you still don’t get it.
— What exactly should I understand? That the apartment is yours? I’ve learned that by now.
— No. That you can’t make promises on behalf of another adult. Even if that person is your wife.
He didn’t say anything in response.
After that threat, talk about moving really stopped. Kirill no longer said that his sister could stay with them ‘for a couple of weeks.’ He didn’t suggest going to sign any papers again. Even the word ‘registration’ almost disappeared from their home.
But the problem didn’t disappear completely.
Anna Sergeevna kept calling her son for a long time, sometimes twice a day. She found another option for Sveta through a distant relative, but this didn’t make her any less upset. To her, Zhanna would always be the woman who ‘didn’t help her husband’s own nephew, despite having a three-room apartment.’
Svetlana was also cold with Zhanna. At family gatherings, she’d say hello, answer questions, and then immediately move on to someone else. Zhanna didn’t try to fix the relationship. She didn’t think she was at fault and didn’t want to endlessly explain her refusal.
At first, Kirill still tried to bring up the old topic with hints.
— By the way, it takes Sveta an hour and twenty minutes to get to work now.
— I see.
— They didn’t get Artem into the school they wanted after all.
— It happens.
— Don’t you feel sorry for them at all?
— I do feel sorry. But that doesn’t change my decision.
After that, he stopped.
Zhanna changed too. Before, she almost automatically saw Kirill’s family matters as her own. Helping his mom with deliveries, picking up Sveta from the repair shop, lending the car for a day, paying for a group gift — no problem. But after the apartment situation, she started asking what exactly they wanted from her and why it was suddenly her responsibility.
Kirill didn’t like this.
— Now you check on every little thing, — he said once.
— Yes, I do.
— All because of that one situation?
— Because in that situation, you made two decisions for me.
He wanted to argue, but didn’t.
The most upsetting part for him wasn’t even that Zhanna refused to register Sveta. What hurt more was that after everything, the word ‘family’ no longer worked as a universal argument for her.
If Anna Sergeevna asked for help, Kirill would now first decide if he could handle it himself.
If Sveta needed something, he no longer said, ‘We’ll help.’ He said, ‘I’ll see what I can do.’
Zhanna never stopped him from helping relatives. She didn’t control his money or demand he stop talking to them. She just wouldn’t let herself or her things be automatically included in someone else’s plans anymore.
A couple of weeks after the whole moving story, Kirill finally told his mom ‘no’ when it came to talking about Zhanna. His mom called one evening while they were having dinner, once again asking why he ‘lets his wife boss him around.’
— Mom, that’s enough, — he said. — We’re done with this.
Zhanna looked up from her plate but didn’t say anything.
«You haven’t finished anything!» Anna Sergeyevna’s voice was loud enough to hear without speakerphone. «You just gave up.»
«This isn’t my apartment.»
He said it stiffly, clearly forcing himself.
«But you’re the husband! You’ve lived there for five years!»
«So what?»
«So you should have a say in this.»
«I do have a say. But I can’t sign things for Zhanna.»
Zhanna kept eating, though she’d lost her appetite. She didn’t want to get involved or turn this rare moment into a public performance.
Anna Sergeyevna wouldn’t let it go.
«So you just left Sveta completely alone?»
«Sveta already found her own place to register. What else?»
«She had to use connections, beg people, and humiliate herself!»
«Mom, she’s a grown woman.»
«Of course. And your wife is supposedly the most grown-up and independent of us all.»
«I’ll call you back later.»
«Don’t you dare give me that ‘later’!»
Kirill hung up.
He sat in silence for a few seconds.
«Thank you,» Zhanna said.
«For what?»
«For not promising her yet another way to try and change my mind.»
«I never promised before, either.»
Zhanna looked at him.
«Kirill.»
«Fine. I did promise.»
He admitted it so plainly, with no big show of regret, that Zhanna believed him more than she ever believed his previous explanations.
But things didn’t go back to how they were before. Before the fight, they could discuss plans almost on autopilot—who to help, what to buy for the parents, where to spend the holidays. Now, every time, Zhanna waited to see if someone had already promised something without telling her. Kirill noticed, and it made him angry.
«Now before every conversation I have to prove I haven’t decided something for you?»
«For now, yes.»
«For how long?»
«I don’t know.»
«How convenient.»
«It’s not convenient for me either. But you did this.»
He sulked, sometimes left the room, sometimes argued that she was holding onto one mistake for too long. Zhanna didn’t fight about how long she’d remember. It mattered more to her that the mistake wasn’t repeated.
One day, Svetlana came to visit her mother, and Anna Sergeyevna organized a family dinner. Kirill went alone. Zhanna had already declined at the invitation stage.
«Mom said she wouldn’t bring up the apartment.»
«Okay.»
«Then why won’t you go?»
«Because I don’t want to spend three hours just waiting for someone to bring it up anyway.»
«You’re just pushing yourself further away from my family.»
«Maybe.»
«Are you really okay with that?»
«I wasn’t okay with your mom coming to me with ready-to-sign papers. Then I wasn’t okay with you pressuring me for three weeks. Then I found out you offered your sister a chance to move in. After all that, I have a right to refuse a family dinner.»
Kirill went alone.
He came back in the evening, looking gloomy. Zhanna didn’t ask for details, but he told her himself:
«Mom thinks you’re deliberately ruining relationships.»
«I see.»
«Sveta said she’ll never ask us for anything ever again.»
«That’s actually kind of convenient.»
«Why would you say that?»
«What am I supposed to say? Convince her she should keep asking for things?»
Kirill tossed his keys on the table in frustration.
«Sometimes it’s impossible to talk to you.»
«And sometimes you just shouldn’t talk to me about things that are already settled.»
After that, he really did stop bringing home every complaint his mother had. Probably not because he completely agreed with his wife, but because he realized: being the go-between for his mother and Zhanna only made things worse for himself.
A few months later, Anna Sergeevna brought up the apartment again. This time, she didn’t mention registration. She told her son it would make sense to someday give him at least a small share, ‘so that a person in marriage can feel secure.’
Kirill didn’t say anything about it at home.
Zhanna found out by accident when he was talking to his mother in the kitchen, thinking his wife was in the shower.
‘Mom, no. Don’t even start. After what happened, I’m not discussing this.’
Zhanna paused in the hallway, but didn’t listen any further.
In a way, he did get it. Not exactly the way she wanted, not immediately and not without resentment. But at least he understood the practical side: if he tried to make decisions about her apartment again, he could actually end up locked out.
Anna Sergeevna didn’t accept this.
She continued to believe her son was ‘living there on shaky grounds,’ even though she had never once said anything like that in five years before that argument. Now it was convenient for her to see the apartment as proof that her daughter-in-law supposedly kept Kirill dependent.
And Kirill found himself stuck between two very simple facts.
His mother wanted him to ‘put his wife in her place.’
His wife had already made it clear where his place would be if he ever tried to bring someone home without her approval again.
That’s why he stopped talking about it out loud.
And maybe that’s what irritated Anna Sergeevna the most: not Zhanna’s refusal, but that her son finally stopped promising her things that never really belonged to him…